Paraphrased and Expanded Version:
Three Cardinals Prospects St. Louis Must Protect If They Become Buyers at the Trade Deadline
As the MLB trade deadline looms just weeks away, the St. Louis Cardinals are caught in a delicate position — a spot many franchises dread: stuck between contending and rebuilding. Currently sitting at 51-46, they trail the third Wild Card slot by only 1.5 games and are positioned in third place within the National League Central. With a postseason push still very much within reach, it’s likely the front office will approach the deadline as buyers. However, this pursuit of short-term success must be handled with caution.
There’s no denying the excitement surrounding a potential playoff appearance. Fans would love to see October baseball return to St. Louis, and the idea of adding talent at the deadline can certainly raise hopes. But that enthusiasm must be weighed against the risks of mortgaging the franchise’s future for a playoff run that might end quickly — especially given the formidable opponents that would likely await them in the postseason, including juggernauts like the Dodgers, Phillies, and division-rival Cubs.
While strategic upgrades are justifiable, the Cardinals would be making a major mistake if they parted ways with any of their top-tier prospects. The organization has invested years into scouting and developing these players — and with the right handling, they could become vital pillars of the next competitive core in St. Louis.
Here are three prospects the Cardinals should consider completely off-limits during trade discussions:
1. JJ Wetherholt – Dynamic Infield Prospect with Star Potential
Among all the rising talents in the Cardinals’ system, shortstop JJ Wetherholt stands out as the crown jewel. Widely considered the club’s No. 1 prospect by MLB Pipeline, Wetherholt has done nothing but validate the hype this season with exceptional offensive production. In 65 games so far, he’s posted a strong slash line of .303/.425/.487, along with 8 home runs and 36 RBI. Now promoted to Triple-A Memphis, he’s already making an impression with a 4-for-11 start.
While Wetherholt may ultimately shift from shortstop to second base — given Masyn Winn’s presence — that versatility only enhances his value. His addition to a young core that includes Winn, Brendan Donovan, Ivan Herrera, and Lars Nootbaar could elevate the Cardinals’ infield depth and offensive ceiling for years to come. His elite bat-to-ball skills, plate discipline, and upside make him simply too valuable to lose in a midseason deal. Trading Wetherholt would be shortsighted and potentially damaging to the franchise’s long-term trajectory.
2. Quinn Mathews – Top Pitching Prospect with Future Rotation Upside
Despite enduring a bumpy season marred by injuries and inconsistencies, left-hander Quinn Mathews remains the top pitching prospect in the organization. Across 11 starts for Triple-A Memphis, he’s compiled a 4.43 ERA — not flashy, but respectable given his missed time and ongoing development.
More importantly, Mathews represents the future of the Cardinals’ rotation. With veteran starters like Miles Mikolas and Erick Fedde nearing free agency and both over 32 years old, a generational shift in the rotation is not just inevitable — it’s necessary. Mathews, with his high ceiling and potential to become a mid-rotation or better starter, could help spearhead that transition.
Letting him go at the deadline — even in pursuit of a playoff boost — would be a gamble that could haunt the team, especially considering how starved they are for young, controllable arms. With a bit more refinement and health, Mathews could very well be starting games in St. Louis before the season ends.
3. Michael McGreevy – MLB-Ready Arm Deserving of a Rotation Spot
Technically still a prospect by innings count, right-handed pitcher Michael McGreevy has already made an impact at the Major League level and should arguably be a permanent member of the big-league rotation by now. In eight career MLB outings (six of which were starts), McGreevy owns a solid 3.05 ERA, showing poise and consistency each time he’s taken the mound.
What makes his situation frustrating is how the Cardinals have continued to rely on aging and inconsistent arms like Mikolas and Fedde, while McGreevy remains underutilized. He’s younger, more cost-effective, and has already proven he can compete at the top level.
Trading McGreevy for a rental veteran — who may only offer marginal improvement or a short-term fix — would be a step backward. Instead, the Cardinals should prioritize giving him a full-time role in the rotation and allow him to develop under the pressures of meaningful baseball. He’s earned that shot.
Final Thoughts:
The St. Louis Cardinals must approach this trade deadline with clarity. Yes, pursuing a playoff berth is worth exploring. But it cannot come at the cost of foundational pieces who could drive the franchise for the next decade. JJ Wetherholt, Quinn Mathews, and Michael McGreevy each bring something irreplaceable to the table — elite talent, positional need, and long-term control.
No matter how tempting the offers, these three should remain untouchable as the Cardinals navigate the thin line between contention and caution.
Leave a Reply